Summary
Practical breakdown of how the default LLC tax treatment works vs. the S-Corp election, using real numbers ($150K profit = ~$21K self-employment tax; Gulf Coast consultant saving $11,500/year net). Covers the administrative costs of maintaining an S-Corp ($3K-$6K/year), the reasonable salary requirement with documentation guidance, Alabama-specific obligations including the Business Privilege Tax and the March 15 federal election deadline, and when to have the conversation with both attorney and CPA. Ends with RFSS CTA.
By: Jordan Gerheim, CEO – Outside Chief Legal LLC
Every Alabama business owner with an LLC eventually asks the same question: should I be taxed as an S‑Corp instead? The answer depends on your specific situation, but understanding how the two structures actually work is the right place to start.
How the LLC Is Taxed by Default
A single‑member LLC is treated as a disregarded entity by default. The IRS sees it the same way it sees a sole proprietorship. All the income passes through to your personal tax return and is subject to self‑employment tax, currently 15.3 percent on the first $168,600 of net earnings, plus 2.9 percent above that threshold.
A multi‑member LLC is treated as a partnership by default. Income passes through to each member’s return and is taxed accordingly. Each member pays self‑employment tax on their share of the profits, regardless of how much they actually drew out of the business during the year.
In both cases, the LLC itself does not pay federal income tax. The owners do. For a business generating $150,000 in net profit, the self‑employment tax on that amount alone is roughly $21,000 before any income tax is calculated. That number is what the S‑Corp election is designed to reduce.
What the S-Corp Election Changes
An LLC can elect to be treated as an S‑Corp for tax purposes without changing the legal structure. The LLC remains an LLC under Alabama law. The change is only in how the IRS treats the income.
With an S‑Corp election, the owner‑operator pays themselves a reasonable salary. That salary is subject to payroll taxes, the same self‑employment taxes in a different form. But the remaining profit of the business, distributed to the owner as a shareholder distribution, is not subject to self‑employment tax.
That is where the savings come from. If your business generates $200,000 in net income and you pay yourself a reasonable salary of $80,000, the remaining $120,000 is distributed as a shareholder distribution and avoids the 15.3 percent self‑employment tax on that portion. On $120,000, that is roughly $18,000 in self‑employment tax avoided. Whether that savings is real depends entirely on what the S‑Corp election costs to maintain.
A Gulf Coast consultant generating $180,000 in annual net profit ran this analysis with their CPA and attorney. At a reasonable salary of $75,000, the S‑Corp election would have shielded $105,000 from self‑employment tax, saving approximately $16,000 per year. Their annual cost to maintain the S‑Corp structure, payroll service, corporate tax return preparation, and additional accounting fees came to roughly $4,500. The net benefit was around $11,500 per year. For that business at that income level, the election made clear financial sense.
What It Actually Costs to Run an S-Corp
The savings calculation cannot stop at the self‑employment tax. The S‑Corp election comes with real administrative costs. You need to run payroll, which requires a payroll service or accountant. You need to file a separate corporate tax return, Form 1120‑S, in addition to your personal return. You need to pay your accountant to handle the additional complexity. You need to set and document a reasonable salary, which the IRS will scrutinize if it appears artificially low.
Alabama also requires an annual report filing for LLCs and has its own Business Privilege Tax, which applies to LLCs regardless of the federal tax election. Neither of those goes away with the S‑Corp election. They are ongoing administrative obligations that stack on top of the federal requirements.
For businesses where the S-Corp election does not make financial sense yet, the threshold is worth tracking annually. As net profit grows, the savings calculation changes. A business that was below the breakeven point at $80,000 in net profit may cross it at $120,000. Reviewing the question each year with your CPA, rather than making a one-time decision and moving on, keeps the election timed correctly rather than either too early or too late.
The businesses that get the timing wrong typically did so because the decision was made in a year when income was temporarily higher than usual. A strong year created the appearance that the election made sense. A more typical year, at a lower income level, means paying to maintain a structure whose savings no longer cover the cost of running it. Modeling the numbers against a typical year, not the best year, and revisiting that model annually is what keeps the election working for the business rather than against it.
The Reasonable Salary Requirement
The IRS requires S‑Corp owner‑operators to pay themselves a reasonable salary for the services they perform. Reasonable means what you would pay someone else to do that same work. An owner who generates $500,000 in revenue but pays themselves a $30,000 salary while taking $470,000 in distributions will attract scrutiny. The IRS has consistently won cases where the salary was set artificially low to minimize payroll taxes.
The reasonable salary determination is not a guess. It should be documented and defensible. Industry compensation surveys, job posting data for comparable roles, and what the business actually paid for similar services before the owner took on that function are all relevant. Getting this number right at the time of election and revisiting it as the business grows is part of running the S-Corp structure correctly.
In practice, documenting a reasonable salary means keeping a record of how the number was determined, not just what it is. Compensation surveys from sources like the Bureau of Labor Statistics or industry-specific publications give a defensible baseline. Job posting data for comparable roles in the Gulf Coast market adds local context. If the business previously paid a contractor or employee for similar work before the owner assumed that function, that payment history is relevant as well. A salary set thoughtfully and documented at the time of election is far easier to defend than one set to produce a favorable tax result and never revisited. The IRS is not asking whether the number feels fair. It is asking whether the number reflects what the market would actually pay for that work.
Setting the salary too low is the most common mistake in S‑Corp elections, and it tends to surface at the worst possible time, during an audit, rather than during the planning stage when it is easy to fix.
What Changes at the State Level
Alabama does not have a separate S‑Corp election process. The federal election with the IRS automatically flows through for Alabama income tax purposes. However, Alabama does impose its own Business Privilege Tax on LLCs and other entities, calculated based on net worth. That tax applies regardless of the federal tax election and is a separate annual obligation.
For multi‑member LLCs considering the S‑Corp election, Alabama’s rules around member distributions, entity maintenance, and annual filings remain in effect. The S‑Corp election changes the tax treatment of income. It does not change the underlying LLC obligations under Alabama law.
When to Have This Conversation
The LLC vs. S‑Corp question is a tax question as much as a legal one. The right answer depends on your net income, your accountant’s fees, your payroll costs, your personal financial situation, and whether the administrative overhead makes sense for where your business is right now.
This is a conversation to have with both your attorney and your CPA together. The legal side covers the election mechanics, the corporate documentation, and the ongoing compliance obligations. The tax side covers whether the numbers actually work for your specific income level and expense structure. Making the election without both perspectives means optimizing one side while potentially creating problems on the other.
A Risk‑Free Strategy Session with OCL is a useful starting point for the legal side of this question. We can walk through the election mechanics, what Alabama requires, and what documentation you need in place before and after the election.
No representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.
Our Corporate/Business Counsel Services
Outside Chief Legal LLC is a modern, forward-thinking law firm serving as fractional chief legal officers and outside general counsel for businesses and their owners. With over 200 years of combined litigation, in-house, general counsel, and administrative legal experience, the firm delivers approachable, comprehensive counsel that blends legal expertise with practical business insight to help clients navigate ownership complexities with confidence. OCL is a trusted partner for founders, business owners, and leadership teams nationwide. Learn more about our firm, meet our team, or schedule a Risk-Free Strategy Session to talk with an attorney about how we can help your company.
